Just wrapped up an interview with pro-legal immigration, former immigration lawyer turned politician Representative Joe Wilson (R) SC. Having posted on Wilson's "You lie" comment to Obama during Obama's speech, I wanted to understand the full context of the remark. Wilson has since apologized to the White House.
Wilson referred extensively to both his packed recess Town Hall experiences and close tracking of pertinent legislation through work with several committees to place his remark in context. While there may be some Republican critics of the comment, Wilson also mentioned several Republicans who have since told him he said precisely what they were thinking but dared not say given the occasion.
Wilson claimed that in over 20 years in politics, having hosted numerous town halls throughout South Carolina over the years, he has never seen anything quite like he witnessed during the recent recess. Crowds suddenly grew from an average of fifty attendees to well over a thousand and approximately 95% of those were there specifically due to concerns over any potential health care legislation. He mentioned several SC cities and towns where that was the case.
Given a great many constituent concerns Wilson has personally heard expressed, he went into the speech hoping Obama would genuinely reach out both to the people and across the aisle to address their concerns. Obama had claimed that would be his intent. Unfortunately, after Republicans were all but shut out of any pertinent on going negotiations in the House, Wilson felt Obama wasn't genuinely reaching out at all and certainly not honestly to the extent that he did.
All Republican amendments for verification, or enforcement regarding efforts to keep American taxpayers from paying for health care, or insurance for illegal immigrants have been defeated by the Democrats. The Congressional Research Service has indicated that, as it stands, there is nothing to prevent coverage for illegal immigrants under currently considered legislation.
Consequently, Wilson pronounced Obama's specific statement in that regard as "appalling". Perhaps Obama simply hasn't kept up on the legislation, being on vacation so much in recent days, as he has.
Wilson also stressed his concern for the existing high unemployment in South Carolina and the potential impact on jobs of new health care legislation. It's been estimated by some organizations that potential legislation could result in the loss of an additional 1.6 million American jobs as small businesses attempt to deal with new guidelines. That at a time when what America needs most is more new jobs, not fewer.
While claiming no desire to see Washington adopt anything akin to the British Parliament's habit of yelling at one another during debate, Wilson felt that constituent interests and emotion just got the best of him in this case. He said he was not angry at all, which is why he didn't go on at the time. Other than the single, short impromptu blurt, Wilson said he was in complete control of himself at all times. He now wishes that he had waited and held a press conference instead.
Perhaps like me and some others, Wilson just reacted naturally when confronted with an obvious misrepresentation dealing with something one has invested a great deal of time in thinking about. He sounded sincere and convincing in both his regret for the impromptu remark, as well as his insistence that, at the end of it all is the fact that Obama simply wasn't telling the truth as any objective observer would understand it in last night's speech.