« Quick Reuters Update | Main | Israeli Blog »

Sunday, August 06, 2006

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d83451c1db69e200d834638c9d69e2

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Hajj Busted Again - Two Media Busts In One:

» Picture Kill: How We Got Here from Ed Driscoll.com
Background here. Details of the above dispatch from Reuters here, here and here. Update (2:41 PM PDT): Here's a trip down memory lane, to try to explain how we got to this point. To start, let's begin with this... [Read More]

» A smoke-clearing blogswarm from Michelle Malkin
Thanks to reader THX -42 Charles Johnson at Little Green Footballs has unleashed an Army of Photo Debunkers and Scrutinizers. Dan Riehl does a big dig here, here, and here. DFH at Drinking From Home looks at two reaction... [Read More]

» Meanwhile, more Reuters Hezbollywood? from MY Vast Right Wing Conspiracy
WTF? Via Ace: Who is this woman? And why does she keep losing all her homes? One on July 22, and another on August 5th? Wow, what are the odds? Rusty Shackelford also finds some possibly (ok, maybe obviously) cloned stuff in a photo of an Israeli... [Read More]

» Reuters Still Owes Us An Explanation from Captain's Quarters
Reuters took a necessary first step in rectifying the insult they gave their customers by publishing the crassly doctored photos supplied by Adnan Hajj. The wire service terminated his employment earlier today: Reuters, the global news and information ... [Read More]

» High Tech Taqqiyah from Sigmund, Carl and Alfred
See Rusty Shackleford and Dan Riehl (Scroll down from the top, here. Dan has a whole series of posts, on what appears to be clear evidence of photo tampering. As we have noted in Useless Ceasefires And The Tragedy Of The Unter-Menschen, In the Arab wor... [Read More]

» Reuters Update from Chris At Home
Adnan Hajj, photographic stringer to the stars of terrorism, has been fired by Reuters for doctoring his photos.The Jawas came to bury Adnan, not to ... [Read More]

» Reutergate 3 from Old War Dogs
Previous related posts here and here. Damn! Sleep a little, miss a lot. I was up nearly all night following the original Reutergate story then let a short nap turn into an all-day thing, now I'm late to the party [Read More]

» Is Lebanon Faked? from Confederate Yankee
This lady is a fraud, as is this jet and its bombs, this ambulance and llama—yes, I said llama—and this bombed city. In each and every one of these events, the professional media's photographers either failed to capture true events,... [Read More]

» U.S. Newspapers Cure Reuters, or Are Complicit from Democracy Project
The current exposure of Reuters’ clear bias in reporting on Israel continues with more photos photoshopped (see here, and here, for examples, and here for a current wrap-up), and its dispatch on the proposed draft resolution for the UN Security... [Read More]

» Reuters Rocked: More Adnan Hajj Photoshopping & The Reuters Lebanese Mystery Woman Who's Always Ready For Her Close-Up from RightWinged.com
****SCROLL FOR UPDATES**** AFP labels one photo with two opposing captions Bear with me through the longwinded opening, it gets good It appears things are only getting worse for Reuters. First, a little background... After being thoroughly busted by th... [Read More]

» Picnic 2006-08-07 from basil's blog
Todays picnic basket of items from my blogroll. ... [Read More]

» Picture Kill from Presto Agitato
...I would expect two of the same type of well-manufactured flare to puff and pop at about the same point and in about the same way, so the substantial similarities between the smoke trails is not evidence of photomanipulation. (And in any case, "I ca... [Read More]

» ReutersGate/2 from The Right Nation
Little Green Footballs, EU Referendum, Power Line, Protein Wisdom, Ace of Spades HQ, The Huffington Post, California Conservative, Daled Amos, Flopping Aces, Blogs for Bush, An Unsealed Room, Euphoric Reality, Captain's Quarters... [Read More]

» Reuters Rocked: More Adnan Hajj Photoshopping & The Reuters Lebanese Mystery Woman Who's Always Ready For Her Close-Up from RightWinged.com
*****UPDATE***** Reuters pulls all Hajj photos. Congratulations conservative blogosphere, you've done it again. SCROLL to the bottom of this post for full details and more updates... ****SCROLL FOR UPDATES**** AFP labels one photo with two opposing cap... [Read More]

» Body Shop Bombed? from Confederate Yankee
This is just surreal: The caption reads: Lebanese civil defense rescuers, try to remove two blanket-wrapped bodies, found trapped under debris and concrete of the destroyed buildings, attacked late Monday by Israeli airstrike, in the southern Beirut su... [Read More]

» The MSM-Hezbollah Ambulance Hoax:All your fakes are belong to us from Michelle Malkin
Take a good look at these three images of Red Cross ambulances in Lebanon, supposedly deliberately targeted by Israel, and broadcast worldwide by the MSM last month: On August 6, I linked to Dan Riehl's excellent post raising questions and... [Read More]

» Brilliant: All Your Fakes Are Now Belong To Us from Ace of Spades HQ
Thanks to CraigC, via the Corner. The Real Stuff: Zombietime destroys the "Israelis Bombed Red Cross Ambulances" fake story, referenced in the video. Zombie builds on Dan Riehl's previous demolition of the fake story.... [Read More]

» Fox News on the ambulance hoax from MY Vast Right Wing Conspiracy
Video from Brit Humes report on the infamous ambulance fraud is at Hot Air. Like Allah says, kudos to Zombie and Dan Riehlwell done! Tags: Hezbollywood, Hezbollah, Hizballah ... [Read More]

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

The hi res red cross photo of the roof of the ambulance has other ambulances in the background in the photograph where you can clearly see the red domes on them.

You can also clearly see that the bomb damage is already rusted over.

Your freelance sleuthing is a little out of control. I'm glad someone found the Reuters smoke picture and outted it. That kind of manipulation doesn't belong in photojournalism. But 90% of the rest of your criticisms of the other photos is more paranoia than anything. For example: who cares that the antenna was rusty. It means nothing. And what is so outrageous about a rescue worker (apparently the team leader) appearing in more than one photograph from a rescue underway - especially when there are so many photographers present? MANY photographers - not just that idiot Hajj. And what is so strange about seeing the same bodies in multiple positions from multiple perspectives (many photographers were there) moved from place to place in a chaotic rescue? Get over it. We may all have different opinions about whether this war is justified, but to stretch and stretch as far as possible to deny that this terrible event even took place undermines your credibility seriously.

omg- imagine watching hajj at "work". Staging the photos-we need more bodies!, then desperately doctoring them-the smoke is not black enough! must-have-more-smoke! Hollywood should make a movie about him-or maybe he should work in hollywood-why waste such talent on something stupid like jihad-it's a dead end job.

Your freelance sleuthing is a little out of control

What you listed were many complaints I personally haven't been following up on. I'd suggest you take it up with the sites which have. As for the antenae, only a fool would say what you have. Of course it matters that the antenae was smashed down into the roof long enough to be caked with rust.

As that's the only item you criticized that pertains to me, I'll just dismiss you as an anonymous and perhaps lazy photo journalist who fears having your ass fact checked.

This really has to be the biggest pile of camel shit todate. Download the high rez shot from the site Dan references. Check it out

1 - close up of the "hole" clearly clean sheet metal and rivet holes

http://img450.imageshack.us/img450/7272/camelshit1fp4.jpg

2 - back up of the whole note how it is "dead" center of the red cross

http://img450.imageshack.us/img450/5083/camelshit2fx1.jpg

3. The kicker the fool who took the shot and made these claims included a very nice shot of an intact "ambulance" notice the "air vent" dead smack in the middle of the red cross on the roof

http://img348.imageshack.us/img348/5837/camelshit3ku8.jpg

This "bomb" hole is nothing more than the removal of that air vent on this ambulance.

Truth matters. Getting at it is sometimes an up-and-down journey, but it shouldn't be the cause for criticism.

This journey has led to another truth that the MSM is not to be trusted. The more 'little facts', however insignificant, the better to dig through to get to the one fact that matters: Some journalists are clearly trying to manage a PR machine that is not on the side of the Israelis.

Kudos to all on the blogs who are working on this. In this war, PR matters a lot. Fie on a dishonest journalist.

The Red Cross is made up of national bodies:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ICRC

Your point, anonymous?

" Because it limits its membership to Swiss nationals only, and because new members are selected by the Committee itself (a process called cooptation), it does not have a policy of open and unrestricted membership for individuals like other legally defined NGOs." <----- ICRC

Just how fast does stuff RUST over there? I thought this was desert! Even Minnesota road salt won’t rust stuff that fast. Look at the "shrapnel cuts"; they are all rusted clean over vs. where the "vent gasket" was; shinny clean. WTF?

In the ITV video that you refer to ie
http://www.videosift.com/story.php?id=6377
Green Helmet appears to be a Red Cross helper in the video as documented on http://balancethemedia.blogspot.com/

Take a look at the first few seconds around 6secs to 12 secs. Take a close look at the "red cross worker on the right". Is he "green helmet"?


Bobby, I don't think that is Green Helmet. The man in the vid and screen shot looks too young, and a little thin in the face to be him. Not so sure about the glasses either.

I´d venture to say we´re looking at a single M789 HEDP or M799 HEI hit on that ambulance, fired by the Apache´s M230 chaingun. Damage by a 70mm rocket is also possible, but I´d expect that to be more severe. It is possible that the round indeed did hit the air vent and blew it away, at least we see some fragmentation damage on the roof, and it is clearly bent inward, which is consistent with a HE hit coming from the top.

the Apache´s M230 chaingun

But the entire roof is caved in. And of course there's the rust. Not to mention that if you look at the hi-res photograph you can see the metal around the hole was bent down in a manner inconsistent with a "hit" and is also rusted - even moreso than the rest of the roof.

It's only a sheetmetal roof, not very strong. In the 80's, my family used to have an Aerostar minivan. When me and my sister would climb up on the roof, it would buckle inward as much as 6 inches - 2 60 pound kids. These vans are at least from the 80's, and it's not hard to imagine that a couple of men could bend the roof inward just by applying a little pressure.

Having personally fired everything from 7.62mm copper jacket bullets to shoulder-fired 84mm HEAT rounds and inspected the results, I'm at a complete loss to imagine what kind of Isaraeli air to ground ordnance could have caused the observed damage pattern. This combined with the fact that the "hit" was scored directly on the air vent (vis ambulances in background in ICRC photos), the fact that the antenna was sucked inward vs blown outward plus the fact that parts of the metal are very rusted while other parts are clean would lead me to believe that this ambulance most likely took a direct hit from a crowbar +/- a few shotgun pellets.

"Truth matters"

Amen

Look into hole on roof. Inside seems suspiciously clean after
receiving round in the roof. Other holes appear to be axe
marks. If round exploded, would have decimated the van.
Really sad attempt

http://thumbsnap.com/v/N2MJZloW.jpg


This is the REAL DEAL...PICTURE OF THE LEBANON BOMBING !

I am looking at all the video footage of Kafr`Qana, and drawing up a timeline, with details of the time/event/stars on screen. It appears so far, that Green Helmet & WHite shirt arrived, and conducted a sound bite, after looking in the building, but prior to doing anything. The the first body comes out, then stacks of bodies, with no apparent injuries are removed, they are clearly visible, despite messrs green & white not noticing them, etc. Finally, the last few bodies are buried and dug out, however most of them are clearly stiff.

I need help, please go through any footage, index it, and send me the links.

Also, on my blog at present there is an analysis of the legalities of the current situation, which I will adapt to show what is necessary for a succesful prosecution for war crimes.

shalom

Phoenix the point is they are national, ie local organisations.

If the accusation is that the local staff have been up to no good then it wouldn't be the first time that such accusations have been made against a local organisation, back during the Bosnian war the local Red Cross was accused of forcing refugees in Brcko to hand sign over their property before they would process them and ship them out of the town. Of course the usual caveats apply, accusations are not proof.

I wanna see this Adnan Hajj mofa's face.

Have a look at http://www.eureferendum.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=2375&postdays=0&postorder=asc&start=15 . There I explained why the damage is pretty much in line with what a M789 HEDP round from the Apache´s M230 chaingun can do.
Of course there are still other possibilities, but to me chaingun hits make the most sense atm.

nice site... look on my site

http://www.desklamp.fora.pl - desk lamp
http://www.lampshades.fora.pl - lamp shades

The comments to this entry are closed.

Donations Appreciated

Blog Ads


Syndigo

AdSense

Infolinks

Search

Wikio Top Fifty

Memeorandum

Blog Roll

February 2012

Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
      1 2 3 4
5 6 7 8 9 10 11
12 13 14 15 16 17 18
19 20 21 22 23 24 25
26 27 28 29      

Find the best blogs at Blogs.com.

2006 Weblog Awards


Technorati


Blog powered by TypePad