Riehl World View: Two Demagogues Self-Destruct

Saturday, August 19, 2006

Two Demagogues Self-Destruct

In the wake of the recent NSA surveillance ruling by judge Anna Diggs Taylor, two noteworthy and purportedly professional sources of anti-Bush rhetoric, the New York Times Editorial Page and blogger Glenn Greenwald, revealed themselves to be little more than shallow-thinking, un-democratic outcomes-based demagogues, as opposed to political commentators interested in good law, or objective truth.

via Instapundit: ADAM LIPTAK in the New York Times: "Even legal experts who agreed with a federal judge’s conclusion on Thursday that a National Security Agency surveillance program is unlawful were distancing themselves from the decision’s reasoning and rhetoric yesterday. . . . Discomfort with the quality of the decision is almost universal, said Howard J. Bashman, a Pennsylvania lawyer whose Web log provides comprehensive and nonpartisan reports on legal developments."

via Dean Barnett at Hugh Hewitt we learn the Times wrote:

A federal judge in Detroit declared the eavesdropping program to be illegal and unconstitutional. She also offered a scathing condemnation of what lies behind the wiretapping — Mr. Bush’s attempt to expand his powers to the point that he can place himself beyond the reach of Congress, judges or the Constitution.

And blogger Greenwald offered an even more laughable response:

I have read the opinion. Here is my immediate analysis of it. It is a very strong opinion in some places, weak in others, but is rather straightforward -- and sometimes eloquent -- in its almost always unequivocal rejection of the Bush administration's arguments....

The evolution of American Law didn't matter a bit to Greenwald or the Times. What mattered was that they were reading the outcome they wanted; how our legal system went about getting there was just so much grist for the mill. That's an extremely dangerous manner of approaching the Law in a constantly evolving democracy.

Our system of laws is based upon logic, reason and precedent for good reason. It is designed to preempt an unfortunate revolution in American law based upon either the temporal will of the masses, or some small minority with a passing control. It is the reasoning behind any judge's ruling which gives American democracy stability, not the ruling itself.

The Times once again displayed its agenda driven shallowness, in this case caring not a wit about what does or doesn't make good legal sense. And Greenwald revealed himself as a superficial hack completely lacking in an understanding of, or an appreciation for the very thing on which he attempts to sell himself as an expert - American law.

It appears the Times Editorial Board is overdue for a much needed vacation. And we have good reason to be pleased that the briefs of Greenwald are more likely collecting sand on a beach in Rio, than crossing the bar of an American court.

Dan on Saturday, August 19, 2006 at 02:50 PM in Politics | Permalink

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d83451c1db69e200d8342f64b953ef

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Two Demagogues Self-Destruct:

» Martyrdom videos: I question the timing! from Alabama Liberation Front
The same day that Crooks & Liars complains that JonBenet is distracting the media from important news like the NSA ruling, the BBC reports that suspects in the London terror plot had made "martyrdom" videos ... [Read More]

» Two Demagogues Self-Destruct from Old War Dogs
In the wake of the recent NSA surveillance ruling by judge Anna Diggs Taylor, two noteworthy and purportedly professional sources of anti-Bush rhetoric, the New York Times Editorial Page and blogger Glenn Greenwald, revealed themselves to be little mor... [Read More]

The comments to this entry are closed.

AdSense

February 2012

Sun	Mon	Tue	Wed	Thu	Fri	Sat
			1	2	3	4
5	6	7	8	9	10	11
12	13	14	15	16	17	18
19	20	21	22	23	24	25
26	27	28	29

Riehl World View

Saturday, August 19, 2006

Two Demagogues Self-Destruct

TrackBack

Comments

Donations Appreciated

Blog Ads

Syndigo

My Other Accounts

AdSense

About

Infolinks

Search

Wikio Top Fifty

Recent Posts

Memeorandum

Categories

Blog Roll

February 2012

2006 Weblog Awards

Technorati

Counter